Men need to feel their indebtedness and their accountability to those that place them in place; first, in order to preserve them from despotism; and, second, that they could also be removed when infirmity calls for the substitution of a competent particular person of their place. Hamlet’s problem is great and there will not be any want of delay, but in case of Othello, there is the necessity of delay. Even among those who believed women had no right to vote, and who did not hesitate to say that Miss Anthony’s punishment was insufficient, there was a large questioning as to his authorized proper to take the case from the jury and enter the verdict of responsible, with out permitting them in any method to indicate their opinion. Second-Because she has been denied the suitable to ask the jury severally whether they assented to the verdict which the Court had recorded for them. Sir, so far as my info in regard to legal proceedings extends, that is the only court in any nation where trial by jury exists, in which the selections which are made in the haste and generally confusion of such trials, will not be subject to overview before another tribunal. Even, below such circumstances, a commoner of England, tried before a jury of lords, would have far much less cause to complain than should I, a woman, tried before a jury of men.
They’re analogs, but one is digital. I admit that there are precedents to maintain such ruling, however they can’t be reconciled with the elemental principles of criminal regulation, nor with essentially the most atypical guidelines of justice. I consider this is a right which was never earlier than denied to a social gathering in opposition to whom a verdict was rendered in any case, either civil or criminal. As then the slaves who acquired their freedom should take it over, or underneath, or by way of the unjust types of legislation, exactly so now should women, to get their right to a voice in this Government, take it; and I have taken mine, and imply to take it at every possible alternative. I believe that to the choices of this court docket, in criminal instances, no evaluate is allowed, except in the identical court docket within the informal approach through which I now ask your honor to assessment the selections made on this trial. The next instances present, and lots of others might be cited to the identical effect, that the proper to poll the jury is an absolute right in all instances, civil and criminal.
To carry that the regulation presumes conclusively that such information exists in all cases the place the legal right is wanting, and to reject all proof to the opposite, or to deny to such proof any impact, as has been accomplished on this trial, is to strike the phrase “knowingly” out of the statute-and to condemn the defendant on the authorized fiction that she was appearing in unhealthy faith, it being all of the whereas conceded that she was in actual fact appearing in good religion. First-Because she has been denied her right of trial by jury. The defence lawyer advised the jury to low cost her as a witness. Precisely as no disfranchised particular person is entitled to sit down upon a jury, and no lady is entitled to the franchise, so, none however a repeatedly admitted lawyer is allowed to apply in the courts, and no girl can achieve admission to the bar-therefore, jury, judge, counsel, must all be of the superior class. But if the info admitted of a doubt of the defendant’s good religion, that was a query for the jury, and it was clear error for the courtroom to assume the decision of it. Immediately after the verdict, Miss Anthony, her counsel, her associates, and the jury, passed out together speaking over the case.